Short Video Feedback

For new video creators stuck at low views who don't know what is wrong. Reviews hooks, edits and thumbnails and says what to change in the next upload.

5 posts in the 3 months to 19 Oct 2026 · r/newtubers

The problem in their words

New creators post videos and stay stuck at low views, like shorts that stall around the same count or a stream that shows no growth after a year. They see a horrible swipe ratio or feel their gaming videos are just slop, but they cannot tell what is actually wrong. They keep trying new hooks, edits and thumbnails without knowing which change matters.

Who's asking

  • r/newtubers: 5 posts

What they use today

  • Zoom ins at the start of shorts
  • Text hooks and verbal hooks
  • Trying a few styles of edits
  • Thumbnails with a background, a character and the game logo

All 5 posts

If you tested it

A headline for the page: “Find out why your videos stall and what to change next upload”

Test first: The riskiest assumption is that stuck creators will pay for a review; test it with a page offering paid feedback and count how many submit a video and pay.

  1. Build a one-page offer: send a video link, get a short review of the hook, edit and thumbnail with clear changes for the next upload, at a set price.
  2. Answer posts in creator help communities where people ask why views are stuck, give one free useful tip, and link the page.
  3. Treat it as a yes if several people pay and submit videos within the 7 days, not just sign up or say it sounds useful.

See a landing page for this idea

How a 7-day test works

Test this idea

Edit it to make it yours, then see who's asking this week. If you want, Ghostlaunch builds the page and runs the 7-day test.

More online business ideas